Daily news

 
Siderov, lies and videotape
12:40 Fri 09 May 2008 - Editorial comment by Clive Leviev-Sawyer
 

Considering what may gently be termed the credibility challenge facing Bulgaria’s justice system, the spectacle of a judge having to adjourn a trial hearing in the face of a courtroom full of jeering boors supporting Ataka leader Volen Siderov is an unhelpful one.

Siderov and his spouse Kapka were in court in Sofia on May 8 because of prima facie evidence that he made false statements when questioned by prosecutors about an August 2006 incident in which he allegedly threatened two people with a pistol after a road collision. Siderov claimed afterwards the incident had been an attempt to assassinate him. When it emerged that the two “assailants” had been a grandfather and his young grandson in a somewhat elderly car, few reasonable people were disposed to believe this claim. But given his unique interpretation of reality, many might expect factual inexactitudes from Siderov.

In court, the judge and two police officers were faced down by a claque of Siderov supporters chanting “Volen”, “innocent” and “mafia”. Television cameras showed a brief consultation between the police and the judge, and an adjournment.

Enormous amounts of time and money have been devoted by Bulgaria’s foreign friends to attempting to reform its court system. The problems of the system are well-canvassed, including a common practice of trials being hindered and postponed because of missing lawyers, missing witnesses and, in the case of a previous hearing involving Siderov, the absence of the accused. On May 8, the court system showed, sadly, that it could be forced into retreat by being shouted down by a bunch of thugs in whose twisted world-view, Siderov is a victim of political persecution, rather than an individual in the dock because in a road rage incident, he whipped out a gun and then allegedly lied afterwards.

Twisted as they may have been by their own inner hatreds and frustrations, the faces of those booing the judge and the court were clearly visible in television coverage. While in many countries, courts may be cleared in the face of such disorder, this would be done so that a trial may proceed. It is difficult to imagine that only two police were deployed to what was certain to be a controversial trial, and it is difficult to understand why more police were not summoned to lead the unruly mob away to be charged individually with contempt of court. The court could easily request copies of the television footage to be used in evidence.

When the trial resumes, it is to be hoped that it proceeds as the rules of court dictate. If there is any further such attempt to howl down the judge, the law should come down with full force on those displaying contempt. Progress has been made in reforming and improving Bulgaria’s court system, and no mob should be allowed to reduce a court day to a media spectacle. The maxim is eternal: Justice must be seen to be done.

* Clive Leviev-Sawyer is Editorial Director of Sofia Echo Media and Editor-in-Chief of The Sofia Echo

 
Printer friendly version
 
 
 
Comments
 
Comments by Antony Miles - 21:59 09 May 2008
Well said Clive! This man deserves to be tried and sentenced, presumably he will be, in a court unobstructed by unruly thugs. Who decided on an almost total lack of police presence? Crazy!
Comments by Mat - 09:04 10 May 2008
Any opportunity for this idiot to show his true colours on TV must be taken, so undermanning the courts police was a great idea. Now people can see the kind of fool they are voting for. It seems that showing up in a Bulgarian court by either defendants or lawyers is purely voluntary and if they have a bit of a sore bottom (like the Marguini) its quite OK for them to stay at home. If the Bulgarian administration can't sort this out, then their justice system should continue to be treated with the utter contempt it deserves.
 
more from News
Google
 
Web www.sofiaecho.com
Free Daily News Alerts
 
BNB Fixing 16 May 2008
EUR1.5474USD
EUR0.7938GBP
EUR1.95583BGN
USD1.26395BGN
GBP2.45337BGN
 
 
 
 
Download first page