Sat, May 26 2012

Green fuel

Fri, Feb 03 2012 09:01 CET 1741 Views 2 Comments
Green fuel

Drilling a horizontal shale gas well in the Appalachian Mountains in the US.
Photo: Meredithw at en.wikipedia

Bulgaria has had or has oil and gas finds in several places, including Chiren, Boutan, Burdarski Geran, Dolni Loukovit and Uglen, to name just some. Hydraulic fracturing, or hydro-fracking, has been used before in the country to prospect and extract oil and gas. It is difficult to give an exact number of how many times, but the latest, according to well engineer Assen Georgiev, was at Buzovets in 1993, using pressure of 500 atmospheres. It was done by the Bulgarian state-owned oil and gas exploration company.

To stimulate extraction rates, the productive rock layer containing oil or gas is fractured by injecting water and sand under pressure. Sometimes, the mix included ceramic grains and, depending on the characteristics of the rock layer, minimal quantities of hydrochloric or sulphuric acid (for carbonate and clay collector layers, respectively). This is done to artificially create new channels in the rock for the gas to flow, raising the effective permeability of the rock layer and opening pathways for the extraction of gas.

Before fracturing, however, the geologic conditions of each location are explored in depth to ascertain whether there are existing underground fractures that would allow the fracking fluid to migrate and contaminate the surrounding geologic area, mainly underground aquifers. A number of criteria need to be satisfied before hydro-fracturing is employed.

The method has been used dozens of times (although it is doubtful anyone has kept any record of the exact number) and there have been no accidents in Bulgaria. I know that from my colleagues who have extensive geological experience in oil extraction.

After fracturing, the wellbore is covered with surfactants – organic compounds, based on hydrocarbons, that increase extraction rates.

There is no fixed range of atmospheric pressure applied in fracking; it all depends on the depth and the exact contents of the rock layer being fractured. As a rule, it has to exceed the geostatic pressure of the rock layer itself, but these are determined in each individual case using lab stress tests and math calculations. According to data from engineer Hristo Kazandjiev, hydro-fracturing in Bulgaria has been carried out with under pressure ranging between 500 and 700 atmospheres.

Parliament's moratorium, which bans any geologic work exceeding pressure of 20 atmospheres, prevents any drilling activity, which is absurd, an opinion shared by the Bulgarian Chamber of Mining and Geology. For example, under this stipulation, should an existing well experience a sudden inflow of hydrocarbons, the engineers would not be allowed to exercise pressure from the top, which would allow the gas to fountain and self-combust, leading to possible injury to the people working on the well.

Hydro-fracking is used in a number of engineering activities; the practice demonised by protesters is not a horrifying prospect, rather a method that has been employed for more than 40 years to serve the energy needs of the Bulgarian society. Hydro-fracking for shale gas extractions is just the next stage in the development of this classic technology.

If fracking is used to prospect for shale gas in Bulgaria, then the horizontal wellbores and the fractures would be between two and three kilometres below the aquifer. Black shale has been discovered in Dobroudja by wellbores at depth between 2.5km and 3.5km as far back as the 1950s. It is known that black shale dates back to the same geologic period as the existing finds of shale gas in the world. The probability that this geologic barrier, thick between three and four kilometres, is fractured in such a way as to allow communication with the aquifer layer is minimal.

The risk lies elsewhere – aquifers always get contaminated in the same way, and that is where the wellbore passes through the aquifer and if is not well isolated. This is why these stretches are made water-tight and cemented additionally, with the quality of the insulation tested before drilling goes any deeper.

There are already more than 200 wellbores in Dobroudja. On each one, the depth of the aquifer is well-known in advance and for that stretch, the well bore is surrounded by several metal pipes, each larger than the other, with the cavity between the pipes filled with cement. This insulation is tested at high pressure to ensure that it is hard enough to resist under strain.

Several finds in Dobroudja – at Tyulenovo, Kamen Bryag and Shabla – are at the same depth with the aquifer; there we have water, oil and a gas cap co-existing in the same porous rocks of the Valanginian aquifer. Oil is being extracted there, but that does not mean that the drinking water in Dobroudja or the seaside resorts, which is extracted from the same rocks, is polluted. If you see it on the spot, you will understand how overblown the fears are.

The two largest accidents ever to happen in Bulgaria – at Chiren and Boutan – are the result of not observing technological procedures and careless actions by the workers on the wellbores. As a result, one person died in the accident at Chiren, while the Boutan wellbore overflowed and caught fire. Both of these were the result of human errors, but had no negative impact on the environment.

Concerning the chemicals used in hydro-fracking, there has been a lot of speculation. I have mentioned earlier what has been used in Bulgaria, but in the world, there are ongoing experiments using fully recyclable gels that can be reused without leaving any traces in the rocks. This solves the issue of the large quantities of water needed for hydro-fracking, but they remain expensive; with the amount of investment in the sector, the prices are expected to go down within several years.

Insofar as prospecting is concerned, prior to the actual drilling, this is 100 per cent safe. Before drilling, a prospective area has to be studied, and that includes geological maps, seismic profiles, geochemical studies of the organic substance that may yield hydrocarbons and physical-mechanical properties of rocks – all of it done in labs. Only four to five years after the start of that process will a first wellbore be drilled to ascertain whether the right kind of rocks is present. If so, a small horizontal wellbore of less than 100m will be drilled to test the possibility of hydro-fracturing and whether it is commercially viable to extract gas.

No reputable expert will claim that this is a 100 per cent safe technology because there are no safe technologies. But Bulgaria's natural environment is damaged much worse by the coal-burning power plants – the most polluted fields in Europe are those covered with ash from the power plants and that can be seen on satellite photographs. We now use that energy because we do not have an alternative. But if we do have an alternative and can reduce the risk to a minimum, as the developed economies of Canada and US are doing, it could be more kind on our nature. This is why the world looks at shale gas as a new green energy source that can ensure humanity's transition from fossil fuels to renewable energy sources.

Kristalina Stoikova holds a Ph.D in geology and is the scientific secretary of the Geological Institute of the Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. She has worked as a scientific consultant for several oil and gas exploration companies, including Texaco, acquired by Chevron in 2001. This first appeared in Capital weekly on January 26.

  • Print
  • Send via email
  • Translate to
  • Share:

Comments

Преглед на профил anonymouse Fri, Feb 03 2012 21:08 CET

A geologist in nine out of ten cases has to make a career employed by mining or exploration companies. Anyone who wants to work in this field has to keep on the right side of the business. It would be professional suicide for the author of this piece to publically express any doubts about the process. There are numerous studies by academic experts employed in European and American universities which question the safety of fracking. The fact she does not even mention them completely undermines her position.

Преглед на профил kylej Fri, Feb 03 2012 20:31 CET

Not that someone who is paid lots of money by gas and petroleum companies would be biased in any way ? This is like Openheimer explaining that the nuclear bomb is a good thing for world peace.


To post comments, please, Login or Register.


Please read the The Sofia Echo forum comments policy.

Bad decision

As debate in Bulgaria heats up on the issue of shale gas exploration, the US ambassador in Sofia weighs in on the topic.

Road less travelled

As debate in Bulgaria heats up on the issue of shale gas exploration, a view against fracking from an environmental campaigner.

Jumping the horse

Bulgarian Cabinet's shale gas ban cuts off all oil and gas exploration drilling.

More in this category

Bulgaria secures one-year extension on Belene loan - minister

The option to postpone the due date was contingent on securing 55 million euro for immediate repayment of the amounts loaned by Belgium's Dexia and Japanese bank Mizuho.

Euro zone unemployment at record high

The Eurostat data agency said that unemployment reached 10.9 per cent in March, up from 10.8 per cent in February. The March figure translates to 17.4 million people unemployed in the euro zone.

Sale of Bulgarian telecom BTC faces cancellation – report

Citing three separate sources familiar with the deal, Capital Daily reports that the creditors found offers submitted by three bidders unsatisfactory.

Raiffeisen takes over Polbank

Eurobank EFG is left with a 30 per cent stake in the merged entity but has said it will exercise its put option on the remaining holding.

Global jobs crisis to continue for some time, ILO report says

The narrow focus of many euro zone countries on fiscal austerity is deepening the jobs crisis and could even lead to another recession in Europe, said the Director of the ILO Institute for International Labour Studies and lead author of the report, Raymond Torres.

Appointments

Employment Agency

Employment Agency

Kamelia Lozanova has been appointed the executive director of the Employment Agency, a position she has held ad interim since September 2011, following the resignation of her predecessor Rossitsa Stelianova. Prior to that, Lozanova was the agency's deputy executive director in charge of international projects and European programmes. She has been with the agency for more than 20 years. Lozanova has a degree in Slavonic philology from the St Kliment Ohridski University of Sofia.

Uniqa

Uniqa

Gloria Dimitrova has been appointed executive director and member of the managing board at Uniqa Life Insurance Bulgaria. Dimitrova began her career in 1998 at the insurance supervision directorate, but moved to the private sector and worked for professional services and insurance brokerage firm Marsh&McLennan and US insurer AIG, both in Bulgaria and the Middle East. She joined Uniqa as regional director for Sofia in 2010. Dimitrova has a degree in economics from the University for National and World Economy in Sofia and a master's degree in insurance from the Business Academy in Svishtov.

Kamenitza

Kamenitza

Yassen Lyubenov is the new head of marketing at Bulgarian beer brewer Kamenitza. Lyubenov has 12 years of experience in marketing in the fast-moving consumer goods sector and has started his career as assistant brand manager at Kraft Foods Bulgaria. He later became brand manager at Wrigley Bulgaria, with responsibilities for Bulgaria and Macedonia. Prior to joining Kamenitza, he was senior marketing manager at Wrigley Russia, where he was in charge of brand expansion into Ukraine, Belarus, Central Asia and the Caucasus. Lyubenov has a bachelor's degree in international business administration from the University of Lincoln, UK.

Beiersdorf

Beiersdorf

Bedros Kalfayan, general manager of skin care and cosmetics company Beiersdorf Bulgaria, will oversee the parent's company units in Romania and Moldova starting April 1. Following company restructuring, Beiersdorf's subsidiaries in the three countries were merged and are now one unit, part of Beiersdorf Central and Eastern Europe. Kalfayan joined Beiersdorf in 2007 as sales manager and was promoted to general manager in 2008. Prior to that, he worked for Axxon Bulgaria, Ferrero and Rubella. Kalfayan has a master's degree in industrial management from the Technical University in Sofia.

Hewlett-Packard

Hewlett-Packard

Sasha Bezuhanova has been appointed Hewlett-Packard public sector director for emerging markets, where she will oversee HP public sector activities in 63 countries, including Bulgaria. Bezuhanova will also be in charge of HP's relations with the European Union. Bezuhanova has been HP's public sector director for Central and Eastern Europe since 2008; before that she was general manager of HP Bulgaria since 1998. Bezuhanova has a master's degree in electronics from the Technical University in Sofia and has completed a managment programme at INSEAD.