Sat, May 26 2012

Proposal for financial incentives for EU states to accept refugees

Tue, May 18 2010 16:48 CET 2704 Views 8 Comments
Proposal for financial incentives for EU states to accept refugees

Uzbek refugees sit in a bus at Timisoara airport, 550 km west of Bucharest, July 29 2005, after arriving from Kyrgyzstan.

European Union member states that volunteer to accept third-country refugees could receive up to 6000 euro for each resettled person under a draft EU law amended by the European Parliament on May 18 2010.
 
EU member states currently contribute far less to refugee resettlement than do other developed countries such as the United States, Australia and Canada.
 
MEPs also approved the setting up of a European Asylum Support Office, following an agreement reached with the European Council, the European Parliament said in a media statement.
 
The EU contributed to only 6.7 per cent of the global resettlement of refugees in 2008, with 4378 individuals.
 
The UN High Commission on Refugees estimates that 747 000 are in need of resettlement. To date, only 10 EU member states have taken part in any resettlement schemes.
 
To encourage more EU states to help in resettlement, MEPs are proposing that they should receive funding of 6000 euro a person for the first year for member states applying for the first time, 5000 euro in the second year and 4000 euro thereafter.
 
The additional amount that newly participating member states receive for the first two years must be invested in developing a sustainable resettlement programme.
 
The programme seeks to resettle in the EU individuals who have been granted refugee status in third countries (for example, Iraqi refugees in Syria), the European Parliament media statement said.
 
It will follow a number of EU priorities, about which the European Parliament and the European Council have yet to agree. 
 
"MEPs wish priority to go to children and women at risk of violence or exploitation, unaccompanied minors, persons with serious medical needs, and survivors of violence and torture. The Council wishes to establish priorities according to the geographic origin and nationality of refugees," the statement said.
 
The European Parliament also approved the creation of a European Asylum Support Office when it adopted a second-reading report by UK Greens MEP Jean Lambert.
 
Based in Valletta, Malta, the office will lend its expertise to member states receiving asylum seekers, the statement said.
 
"It will seek to strengthen co-operation among national authorities and afford administrative support to member states subject to particular pressure," according to the statement.
 
The European Parliament and the European Council agreed at second reading to assign the office the task of co-ordinating information exchange on resettlement measures carried out by member states.
 
An EU decision establishing a European Refugee Fund is expected to be amended to ensure that it is adequately funded, when MEPs vote on May 19 2010 on a report by Claude Moraes (S&D, UK) on this matter.
 
On April 30 2010, UNHCR head António Guterres urged EU members to serve as examples of the proper treatment of refugees and to forge a cohesive regional response to new forms of forced displacement, including population movement caused by the effects of climate change.
 
Speaking at the European Parliament in Brussels, Guterres said that in the 27-member EU, where internal borders have largely disappeared, people seeking protection should be able to find it.

He said that the number of refugees and internally displaced persons (IDPs) worldwide has remained relatively stable in recent years, as has the number of asylum applicants reaching industrialised countries. He attributed the trend to little change in the number of conflicts and the difficulty of ending them.
 
"Crises are either not solved or – once solved – quickly slip back into instability or even open war," the UN News Service quoted him as saying.
 
Guterres said that the number of refugees that the UNHCR was able to help to return to their homes last year fell to below 400 000, less than half the number of people helped to go back home in 2008.
 
He voiced concern over the increasing difficulty faced by humanitarian agencies trying to deliver assistance to refugees and IDPs.
 
"In many parts of the world, we see growing threats to the security of humanitarian workers, including our own," he said.
 
He also drew attention to the numerous interlinked causes of forced displacement.
 
"Climate change is an accelerating factor for displacement and instability, but water scarcity, food security, population growth and urbanisation can all trigger conflict," he said.
 
He said that the UNHCR had no plans to seek a revision of the 1951 Refugee Convention, but expressed the agency’s interest in becoming a catalyst for a debate about how to deal with the human rights impacts of forced displacement this century.
 
"We need to find integrated approaches and we hope that the EU will help in this," he told MEPs.
 
Commenting on asylum in the European context, Guterres said that while states had the right and duty to manage their borders and to define their migration policies, they must do so in a way which respects international law.
 
There must be safeguards, he said, to ensure that asylum-seekers have access to territories and procedures where their claims can be examined.
 
He lamented the fact that, at present, many of those in need of international protection have little choice but to enter the EU by irregular means and, in so doing, may fall victim to smugglers and human traffickers.
 
The rejection rate of asylum claims of people of one nationality can vary from 95 per cent in one country to near zero in another, he said, depending where the claim is made.
 
"This is a dysfunctional situation, leading people to move irregularly within the (European) Union," he said.
 
Guterres thanked the European Commission and the EU member states for their consistent support of UNHCR’s work, noting that together they provided more than 40 per cent of the refugee agency’s annual budget.
 
 

  • Print
  • Send via email
  • Translate to
  • Share:

Comments

Anonymous to clarify... Fri, May 21 2010 13:24 CET

...some apparently mistaken assumptions about refugee resettlement.

(1) Refugees are not economic migrants. They are fleeing conflict or have been persecuted in their country of origin for a variety of reasons, often for things they can't change (i.e. race or religion, or political views).

(2) These are refugees that cannot go home and have no foreseeable prospects of doing so. Many of them are woman-headed households, or survivors of violence nad torture, or others with a very difficult past. They also cannot stay in their country of asylum - some countries offer [...]

Read the full comment no asylum, or others, like Ethiopian refugees in Sudan, are only persecuted further. Resettlement is pretty much a last option.
(3) Only 1 percent of all refugees even get resettled. The fact that Europe takes about 4000 and the US takes about 70000 is indicative of Europe's disintrist.

Anonymous Marilyn Shepherd Thu, May 20 2010 21:03 CET

Have Europe and most of the world forgotten why we have the refugee convention?

Anonymous Valeri Wed, May 19 2010 15:49 CET

Well said Aries..

Anonymous Ares Wed, May 19 2010 08:09 CET

The EU should pay that money, since it has plenty(!), to the "refugees' to return to their country of origin helping them up start anew. If the economic migrants, or illegal immigrants are able to contribute to their "adopted" second country, they must be able to contribute to their own country as well, and be amongst their own.


EU will also save lots of money by dismantling the "human rights" industry that thrives in the wrong places, ie the destination of the problem and not the origin.
Perhaps EU should finance them [...]

Read the full comment too to follow their clients to their country of origin and fight with their governments, courts there.

Anonymous Cosmos Tue, May 18 2010 21:36 CET

For the price tag of 6000 Euro per unit I will take 50.

Anonymous Valeri Tue, May 18 2010 21:03 CET

Anthony,
I am still flabbergasted about your choice to evoke Capitalism - why, because there's money involved?

One government, paying money to another government - where is Capitalism in all that?

This is how lost some folks are....

Anonymous Valeri Tue, May 18 2010 20:59 CET

No it means that the richer countries will dump muslims on the poorer ones, who's governments need the money and don't care enough about their countries futures - nothing to do with capitalism, where would you get that from...

I think they are getting the idea from Obama's dumping his Muslim combatants on his poorer NATO "allies", who need stuff, so it's easier to make them offers they can't refuse ...

Anonymous Anthony Ratkov Tue, May 18 2010 19:59 CET

It means that they are not really accepting refugees for humanitarian reasons,they are actually accepting refugees so they can get the six thousand euros. It's another example of the immorality that comes with capitalism.


To post comments, please, Login or Register.


Please read the The Sofia Echo forum comments policy.

Human Rights Watch report condemns European attitude to torture

Human Rights Watch says France, Germany, and the United Kingdom co-operate with foreign intelligence services that routinely use torture

EU states granted protection to 78 800 asylum seekers in 2009

The largest groups given protection status were from Somalia, Iraq and Afghanistan. Bulgaria approved 280 refugee status applications in 2009; while the UN says that the number of refugees voluntarily returning to their home countries last year plummeted to their lowest levels in 20 years.

Claims of asylum inconsistently examined across European Union – UN

The 12 countries studied for the report, which also applauded successes such as good cross-cultural communications skills, were: Belgium, Bulgaria, the Czech Republic, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Italy, the Netherlands, Slovenia, Spain and the United Kingdom.

Migrants are ‘an opportunity for host societies’, European church meeting told

The role of the Church should be to stand with migrant brothers and sisters, says the head of the Churches’ Commission for Migrants in Europe.

Top UN refugee official welcomes Greece’s plans for asylum reform

Until the asylum reforms are carried out, UNCHR said it will continue to recommend that other European states not send asylum-seekers back to Greece – as the first point of entry into Europe – under EU or other regulations.

More in this category

Global food prices ease, but stay high, FAO says

The global food import bill in 2012 could decline to $1.24 trillion, down slightly from last year’s record of $1.29 trillion.

Bulgarian Olympic champion sentenced to nine years' jail in Brazil

Boevski has been under arrest in Brazil since October, when he was arrested at Sao Paulo's international airport with nine kg of cocaine in his luggage.

Bulgarian media tinted by owners' other interests – SEEMO report

Whereas foreign media ownership is perceived as advantageous for media outlets and journalists, Bulgarian owners are perceived as investors with short-term vision who strive for immediate profits.

Prevent violent extremism by being better at identifying people at risk of radicalisation – Malmström

Killing spree in Norway in July 2011 and the arrests of individuals in a number of EU member states for the preparation of terrorist attacks, are proof of the continuing need for vigilance, Europol says.

On annual World Book Day, UN emphasises importance of translation

In her message to mark the Day, Bulgaria's Bokova said that books are 'valuable tools' for knowledge-sharing, mutual understanding and openness to others and to the world.