Thu, Feb 09 2012

The Sofia-Kardam train disaster case ends with jail sentences

Tue, May 04 2010 17:10 CET 2264 Views 7 Comments
The Sofia-Kardam train disaster case ends with jail sentences

Two employees accused following the 2009 Sofia-Kardan train fire disaster case, which resulted in nine deaths inside a train couchette on February 28 2008, have received a total of 20 years in jail, Darik Radio said.

On May 4 2010, the Regional Court in Pleven found two of the three accused employees of the state-owned Bulgarian Railway Company (BDZ) - Georgi Georgiev, the person in charge of the couchette carriage, and train-commander Ivanka Kostadinova - guilty of failing to comply with their duties and breaching safety rules for passengers.

Georgiev was given 12 years in jail while Kostadinova got eight years. Both Georgiev and Kostadinova were on the train when the carriage caught fire in the middle of the night.

Georgiev was also found guilty of drinking alcohol on duty. Together with Kostadinova, he had failed to secure the evacuation of sleeping passengers from the burning carriage. They had also failed to ensure that fire extinguishers were properly maintained and in their correct positions, the court ruled.

The third defendant, Georgi Ivanov, deputy director of BDZ's Passenger Transport company, was found not guilty.

Georgiev, Kostadinova and BDZ were also sentenced to pay 100 000 leva to relatives of each of the nine victims.

The sentences can be appealed in the next 15 days.

One of the main points of public dissatisfaction during the case was that the carriage doors were locked. According to the prosecution, this was one of the reasons for the failed evacuation. According to the defendants, the order was issued to ensure the safety of passengers' belongings.

Defendants also claimed that the fire started so quickly that it was impossible to arrange a proper evacuation procedure.

The disaster was caused by a fire that erupted at about midnight on the train from Sofia to Kardam on the Romanian border, in the Dobrich region. As the train entered Cherven Bryag, the fire started in a couchette carriage, which contained 35 passengers at the time, and then spread to a sleeping compartment with 27 people.

Nine people died in one of the carriages, sparking widespread public discussion about the condition of BDZ. The committee was tasked with probing the causes of the fire and actions undertaken by railway employees to prevent the accident, but also to examine the regulatory framework concerning railway transport safety.

  • Print
  • Send via email
  • Translate to
  • Share:

Comments

Anonymous*******Tue, May 17 2011 06:34 CET

This comment has been removed by the moderator because it contained foul, abusive or discriminating language

Anonymous ahum Fri, May 07 2010 14:56 CET

"Georgiev was also found guilty of drinking alcohol on duty"

If he gets punished for this you might as well send home 75% of all working Bulgarians.

Anonymous 1 Wed, May 05 2010 11:31 CET

"They had also failed to ensure that fire extinguishers were properly maintained and in their correct positions".

biggest load of crap i have ever heard. This is like asking the air-hostesses to check the oil on the jet-engine before push back.

And exactly how to you ensure an evacuation when more than likely the cabin is filled with smoke..? Once a fire starts you have about 90 secs. for a safe evacuation whilst the train is moving. Even if the cabin rooms were locked surely the cabins windows could have provided an [...]

Read the full comment out.

Anonymous 13 Wed, May 05 2010 08:43 CET

So what was the cause of the fire!?

Anonymous kiril Wed, May 05 2010 03:32 CET

this sounds like a ridiculous witchhunt for scapegoats. and yes, what about the smokers that actually caused the fire? Once again a case of Bulgarians beating each other up just as it was in the communist days with outlandish prison terms and not enough cause and effect to justify them.

Anonymous UndertheCovers Tue, May 04 2010 19:55 CET

I don't know an overnight sleeper train that does not have locked doors. It is a European norm.

Most travellers are obsessed with being raped or robbed on sleepers and wouldn't have it otherwise.

Anonymous smokers Tue, May 04 2010 18:25 CET

What about the smokers?


To post comments, please, Login or Register.


Please read the The Sofia Echo forum comments policy.

BDZ to increase seating capacity and facilitate traffic over St George weekend

In total, BDZ are saying they will make available about 10 000 additional seats on 105 trains between May 5-10.

Sofia - Kardam train disaster case resumes on September 3

The disaster was caused by a fire which erupted at about midnight on the train from Sofia to Kardam on the border with Romania, in the Dobrich region, killing nine people and injuring many others

Editorial: Bulgaria’s state railways are in a state

The phrase "a hell of a way to run a railroad" is extremely apposite regarding Bulgarian State Railways, BDZ.

Sofia-Kardam train fire investigation closes on June 6

On June 6, the ad hoc parliamentary committee charged with investigating the circumstances that caused the deadly fire on the Sofia-Kardam train on February 28, is expected to finish its work. The committee was set up on March 6, initially with a term of one month, which was later extended by two more months, private broadcaster bTV reported. Nine people died in the train fire in one of the carriages, sparking renewed public discussion about the plight of the Bulgarian State Railways (BDZ). The committee was charged with probing the causes of the fire and the actions undertaken by railways employees to prevent the accident, but also to look into the regulatory framework concerning railway transport safety.

French expert says Sofia-Kardam probe hindered by lack of co-ordination

Bad co-ordination between the different institutions investigating the Sofia-Kardam train fire, which took the lives of nine people in February, was the main obstacle in the way of the probe, according to a report authored by French expert Jean-Gérard Koenig, quoted by mediapool.bg on April 14. Koenig is the head of the French government's land transport accidents investigation bureau BE-ATT and was in Sofia at the invitation of Bulgaria's Transport Ministry to help with enquiries into the deadly train fire.

Bulgarian train fire final death toll reaches nine people

The final death toll of the train fire from February 29 2008 has reached nine people, a forensics team said on March 4, as quoted by Dnevnik daily. Six bodies had been identified over the weekend and the team has confirmed the identities of the last two, doctor Dancho Dekov said, as quoted by the newspaper. The team also found remains of another person, who was until then presumed missing, he added.

More in this category

Bulgarian Parliament passes controversial Forestry Act amendments

Opposition parties and environmental protection NGOs argued that this and other provisions were the result of lobbyist pressure from ski resort operators.

Bulgaria, Romania suspend shipping on Danube River

Ferry-boat service between the Bulgarian and Romanian banks of the river may continue if the ferry captains decide that the weather conditions allow the safe passage of the boats.

European auditors suggest 'more efficient' use of EU funds for nuclear decommissioning in Bulgaria

Bulgaria shut down two 440MW units at its Kozloduy nuclear power plant in 2004 and two more units with the same installed power in 2006.

US ambassador requests $50 000 USAID for Bulgarian flood victims

We hope this donation can assist those communities which are suffering, and especially those who have lost their homes, James Warlick says.

‘Stronger action’ needed by Bulgaria to implement EC recommendations against crime, corruption

February 8 EC report notes a number of developments in Bulgaria’s progress in judicial reform, the fight against corruption and organised crime, but points to need for stronger action in a number of areas.