Sat, Feb 11 2012

Book burning in Ukraine stokes controversy about history

Thu, Mar 18 2010 10:46 CET 6066 Views 1 Comment
Book burning in Ukraine stokes controversy about history

Photo: Marcus Obal

Russian nationalists in Crimea have burned Ukrainian history textbooks to protest what they say are distortions of the past by the administration of former President Viktor Yushchenko.  The recent transfer of power in Kyiv has raised hope among Russian nationalists and fear among Ukrainians.

On Sunday, Russian nationalists in the Crimean port city of Sevastopol, home to Russia's Black Sea Fleet, threw Ukrainian history textbooks into boxes at the foot of a local monument to Russian empress Catherine the Great.  The books were to be turned into pulp.

More history texts were burned the following day at another demonstration in Simferopol, the capital of Crimea.  

Among the participants was Sevastopol city councilman Yevgeniy Dubovik, a member of the pro-Russian and far left Progressive Socialist Party of Ukraine.  He agrees with the warning of 19th century German writer Heinrich Heine who wrote, "Where they burn books, they will in the end burn people."

Nonetheless, Dubovik told VOA that Monday's burning of Ukrainian history books was justified.

Dubovik says his group burned literature that promoted fascism in Ukraine, and they will continue to burn and trample it.  He condemns the books, saying they seperate people and destroy the mutual love between Russians and Ukrainians.  Dubovik adds that perhaps even toilet paper will be made out of the books.  He acknowledges the chosen method may be harsh, but thinks it is the right one.

Unlike history texts promoted by former President Viktor Yushchenko, those of the Soviet era ignored or condemned Ukrainians who fought against Russian or Soviet imperial rule.  Pro-Russian forces also resent Mr. Yushchenko's campaign to teach the Ukrainian language to schoolchildren in Russian-speaking regions of the country.  

Another bitter point of contention is the former president's decision to have young Ukrainians learn about the so-called Holodomor, a Kremlin-inspired famine more than 75 years ago that was aimed at collectivizing Soviet agriculture.  The tragedy claimed the lives of millions of Ukrainians and other Soviet peoples, including Russians, Belorusyns, Moldovans, Crimean Tatars, Kazakhs and Jews.  Any mention of the Holodomor was strictly forbidden in the USSR.  

Yevgeniy Dubovik says there is no point in dwelling on the past, because everyone knows about the famine anyway and life after collectivization was fine.

Protest organizers in Crimea say they are counting on newly elected President Viktor Yanukovych to downplay Ukrainian history and language and to improve ties with Moscow.

Meanwhile, many Ukrainians, particularly in the western part of the country, fear controversial new Education Minister Dmytro Tabachnyk will promote pro-Russian policies.  Tabachnyk has raised eyebrows with statements that suggest western and eastern Ukraine should be separated, or should never have been united in the first place.

In a protest against him on Monday in the city of Lviv, Ukraine's Congress of Young Nationalists collected old Soviet history books to turn them into pulp.  

The organization's local leader, Andriy Ben, rejects broad Soviet-era accusations that western Ukrainians were all Nazi war collaborators.  He told VOA he is willing to discuss ways to discuss the apparent divide over Ukrainian history with opponents in Crimea.

This divide, says Ben, is exacerbated on purpose by politicians who play political games.  The activist believes there is actually no gap among ordinary people.  As for Tabachnyk, Ben says petition drives are being held against him, not just in western Ukraine, but also in Kyiv and such eastern and southern cities as Kharkiv, Kherson, and even Odesa.  

Mr. Tabachnyk was not available to comment about the controversy surrounding his appointment or the book burning.

The president of the prestigious Kyiv Mohyla Academy, Serhiy Kvit, is among the new Education Minister's prominent critics.  Kvit told VOA the recent destruction of books in Ukraine is not so much a tragedy, as it is a farce.  He adds that the Tabachnyk controversy is a teachable moment made possible by freedom on speech.

The university president says if anyone tried to eliminate freedom of speech, which Ukrainians enjoy on news programs and talk shows, he would have very big problems.  Kvit says Ukrainians today openly discuss and express everything, which is the main achievement of the [popular 2004 protest known as the] Orange Revolution.  

Kvit adds that most contemporary Ukrainian politicians are heavily influenced by Soviet-style thinking, but even they understand the reality of free speech in Ukraine, which remains despite changes in government.

Serhiy Kvit and other leading Ukrainian university officials have posted arguments against Tabachnyk on the Internet, where the Minister's critics have also created a special protest page.  More than 800 people have joined a Facebook group that opposes his appointment.  

  • Print
  • Send via email
  • Translate to
  • Share:

Comments

Anonymous Valeri Thu, Mar 18 2010 21:09 CET

"The recent transfer of power in Kyiv has raised hope among Russian nationalists and fear among Ukrainians."

Obviously the author is a Ukrainian nationalist, because this is a very misleading characterization. It's designed to leave the impression that it's Russians against Ukrainians, when in fact the last elections included 100% Ukrainian voters. It's the fact that Ukrainians are divided that he is trying to cover up and present it as an international problem that would warrant American involvement.


To post comments, please, Login or Register.


Please read the The Sofia Echo forum comments policy.

Ukrainian protest against pro-Russian policies

Policies of Ukrainian president Viktor Yanukovych, perceived by many to be pro-Russian, have sparked demonstrations outside of parliament in Kyiv. Inside, lawmakers discussed damages from last month's egg-throwing brawl over one of those policies.

EU foreign ministers to discuss Haiti, Chile

Afghanistan, Middle East, Libya - Switzerland dispute, Ukraine, Moldova, Croatia, Greece and the future European External Action Service on the agenda for meeting on March 22 2010.

Former finance minister becomes Ukraine's prime minister

New Ukrainian prime minister Mykola Azarov seen as loyal to president Viktor Yanukovych.

Tymoshenko cabinet ousted by vote in Ukraine's parliament

If a new government cannot be formed within 60 days, new parliamentary elections will have to be held.

New Ukrainian president meets EU leaders in Brussels

Viktor Yanukovych seeking to position his country as a bridge between Europe and Russia.

Ukraine: political and economic stabilisation needed, MEPs say

European Parliament resolution calls for political and economic stabilisation including constitutional reform, the rule of law, involvement in minorities in the political process, a social market economy and combating corruption.

Ukraine's president Yanukovych outlines policy vision

New Ukrainian president Viktor Yanukovych touts domestic reforms, non-aligned foreign policy

More in this category

Auction reveals Ceausescu’s personal age of plenty

Iranian silver-plated pigeons, African leopard skins and a Chinese bronze yak were among the 70 items sold in an auction of gifts presented to Romania’s former dictator Nicolae Ceausescu and his wife Elena.

EC praises airports for progress in dealing with extreme weather

Airports were also showing signs of better co-ordination and providing passengers with accurate real-time information, compared to previous period of travel disruption, transport commissioner Siim Kallas said.

Hungary's PM condemns international critics amid economic uncertainty

Viktor Orban defends government's record, new constitution in state-of-the-nation address as he slams European Commission.

Polish PM, digitalisation minister hold public debates on ACTA ratification

PM Donald Tusk invited authors, NGOs, experts and bloggers to a debate on the ACTA copyright agreement, but several key organisations, including the Helsinki Foundation, rejected the invitation claiming that the talks will likely offer no opportunity to discuss concrete issues.

Protesters clash in Budapest as controversial theatre director takes stage

'Dirty Jews' and 'Dirty Nazis' were the most popular chants when two groups clashed in front of Új Színház (New Theatre)