Sat, Feb 11 2012

Policy brief: Estonia and the euro zone

Thu, Mar 11 2010 17:44 CET 5509 Views
Policy brief: Estonia and the euro zone

The financial storm, which started in US financial markets in 2008 and immediately spread across the world, refuses to calm down. The global financial crisis has now reached European government debt markets, where Greece has experienced problems rolling over existing debt and placing new debt. The Greek interest rates have increased markedly since the third quarter of 2009. The interest rate on 10-year government bonds hovered around 6-6.5 percent in February 2009, approximately 3 percentage points above the interest rate on similar German bonds.

The difficult situation in Greece is partly the result of investors having less appetite for risk because of the global financial crisis, but investor confidence has also been shaken by a number of specific issues. First, the Greek government surprised the markets in the autumn 2009 by revising the 2009 budget deficit up from 6 to around 12 percent of GDP. This came on the back of a history of substantial deficits even during economic booms. Second, the public debt in Greece has amounted to around 100 percent of GDP for decades and is set to grow substantially. Third, it has emerged that the Greek authorities at times have been hiding parts of the budget deficit using complex financial transactions.

A number of other euro area countries have also experienced increasing government deficits and higher risk premia on government debt. This applies in particular to Portugal, Ireland, Italy and Spain. The PIIGS has become the rather unflattering label of this group (based on the countries’ initials). It is noticeable, however, that Ireland seems to have attained renewed stability after implementing a harsh austerity package with cuts in welfare payments, public sector wages etc.

The debt crisis in Greece has offered new challenges to the European Union in general and the euro area in particular. The crisis has been associated with a recent depreciation of the euro although the improved international competitiveness has been welcomed by many. The main fear is that the Greek crisis spreads to the rest of the PIIGS and possibly also other countries in the EU. At the time of writing (1 March) the euro area countries have expressed support to Greece, but no concrete plans have been put forward.

Estonia aspires to join the euro area in 2011
The Estonian government is seeking membership of the euro area from 2011. The process of accession to the euro area bears many similarities to a beauty contest, in which the focus is on the "essential measurements" and where the contestants are assessed by several judges. In the context of euro area membership, the applicant country must satisfy the Maastricht convergence criteria and this is assessed in convergence reports produced by the European Commission and the European Central Bank. The final decision is made by the Council of Ministers.

The forthcoming convergence reports for 2010 will be published in April or May. At present it seems likely that Estonia will be found to satisfy all of the Maastricht criteria. The fiscal criteria are satisfied as the 2009 government deficit is estimated to 2.6 percent of GDP and the gross government debt will end at around 7.8 percent of GDP (see Figure 1). The price stability criterion is satisfied since Estonia presently has negative inflation. The exchange rate criterion is also satisfied, because Estonia has had a currency board with a fixed exchange rate since 1992. The interest rate criterion cannot be assessed, since Estonia does not issue long-term government bonds.

It is noteworthy that the 2009 government deficit is below the 3 percent threshold of the fiscal criterion given that Estonia experienced a deep recession in 2009 with an estimated GDP fall of 14 percent. This performance reflects several rounds of budget cuts and tax increases, implemented both in 2008 and 2009. While the budget consolidation may have inflicted substantial social costs, it proves that it is possible to restrain government deficits even in adverse times (see also Staehr 2010.)

Estonia is unique among the EU countries by the central government having accumulated reserve funds based on privatisation and other extraordinary revenues as well as budget surpluses. At the end of 2009 the central government reserves amounted to approximately 8.9 percent of GDP (Estonian Ministry of Finance). The reserves have provided liquidity in situations where government borrowing would be difficult or very expensive. The fiscal room for manoeuvre provided by the reserves also allowed Estonia to participate in the IMF-led bailout of Latvia in the autumn 2008. Estonia has pledged to lend 100 million euro to its southern neighbour.
  • Print
  • Send via email
  • Translate to
  • Share:

To post comments, please, Login or Register.


Please read the The Sofia Echo forum comments policy.

Moderate earthquake hits Greece on March 12

The epicentre was triangulated at about 180 kilometres south of Athens, in the sea, southeast of the Peloponnese

More in this category

Average monthly salary in Bulgaria rose in Q4 2011, statistics institute says

In the fourth quarter of 2011, the average monthly salary increased to 727 leva, 4.9 per cent higher than in Q3, the National Statistics Institute says.

Global food prices rebound, FAO says

For the first time in six months, global food prices rose overall in January 2012, the UN Food and Agricultural Organisation said.

Bulgaria mulls tighter regulation of bank fees - updated

The package will be discussed with the Association of Bulgarian Banks before the amendments are submitted to Parliament.

Bulgarian ICT Watch event in March

Debate at the half-day event will cover what has been achieved so far and what further can be done by the Bulgarian Government to support development of the market.

Movers and shakers

Selectivity, not popularity, is the driving force behind Sofia's most exclusive members' only club.

Appointments

British Council

British Council

Lyubov Kostova was appointed country manager of British Council Bulgaria effective January 1, replacing Tony Buckby, who left in October 2011 to take a similar position at British Council Greece. Kostova has been with British Council Bulgaria for 11 years, as public communications manager and, since 2008, as the head of project and partnerships department. Prior to joining the British Council, Kostova was head of international activities at the National Academy for Theatre and Cinema Arts (NATFIZ). She has a degree in Indian studies from Kliment Ohridski Sofia University.

CEZ

CEZ

Stefan Apostolov is the new chief executive of CEZ Razpredelenie Bulgaria, the power transmission subsidiary of Czech energy company CEZ in the country. He replaces interim chief executive Ales Damm, who remains the chairperson of the CEZ Razpredelenie management board. Apostolov has 30 years of experience in the energy sector, joining CEZ in 2007 as director of customer service and was later appointed as head of business development. Apostolov has a master's degree in electric systems from the Belorussian National Technical University in Minsc, management diplomas from Open University London and New Bulgarian University, as well as a master's degree in business administration from Plovdiv University.

BASF Bulgaria

BASF Bulgaria

Valentina Dikanska is the new general manager of chemical industry giant BASF subsidiary in Bulgaria, taking over from Herbert Fisch, BASF vice president for Southeastern Europe. Dikanska, who started her career as an expert in the Finance Ministry, joined BASF Bulgaria as director of finance and administration in 2002. She becomes the first Bulgarian to hold the top management position in the company in its 40-year history on the Bulgarian market. Dikanska holds a master's degree in economics from the University for National and World Economy in Sofia.

Rompetrol Bulgaria

Rompetrol Bulgaria

Alexander Albin has been appointed chief executive of fuel distributor Rompetrol Bulgaria, replacing Nichita Sorin, who left to become chief executive of Rompetrol Gaz in Romania. Albin was previously chief executive of Rompetrol Georgia. He has more than 15 years of experience in the oil and gas industry; prior to joining Romania's oil group Rompetrol in 2008 as an adviser, he oversaw operations at Atyrau refinery in Kazakhstan, owned by Rompetrol's parent company KazMunaiGaz. He previously held top management positions at two other leading Kazakh oil and gas companies.