Fri, Feb 10 2012

Bone of contention

Fri, Jan 29 2010 10:00 CET 4098 Views 3 Comments
Bone of contention

Bozhidar Nanev

Photo: Nadezhda Chipeva

As the limelight shone brightly on the fallout from Bulgaria’s then Foreign Minister Roumyana Zheleva’s grilling during her European Commission confirmation hearings, the allegations about a possible conflict of interest involving another minister in Prime Minister Boiko Borissov’s Cabinet quickly disappeared in the cloud of dust raised by Zheleva’s fall.

Health Minister Bozhidar Nanev has maintained a low profile since taking office, despite the simmering debate on the direction of health care reform in Bulgaria. Were it not for his fellow minister’s ordeal, his name would likely have been the subject of more headlines in January.

The subject of the controversy is Nanev’s visit to the United States in November 2009, a trip on which he was accompanied by the chairperson of Parliament’s health care committee Luchezar Ivanov and the head of the Transplants Agency Teodora Djaleva.

The trip was paid for by two non-government organisations, the Americans of Bulgarian Descent Federation and the Euro Atlantic Fund. Both NGOs are chaired by Roumen Hichev, who was identified in the English-language official correspondence preceding the visit as Roman Hitchev.

Hichev is the vice president for international activities at Osteotech Inc, a US firm that describes itself as a "global leader in the processing of human bone and connective tissue for transplantation", and the managing director of Osteotech’s Bulgarian subsidiary, Osteocentre tissue bank.

The goal of the visit was meetings "with leaders and experts from the US medical community", according to paperwork made public by Osteocentre. The meetings schedule, published by Osteocentre, featured US health department assistant secretary for planning Donald Moulds and John Monahan, director of the health department office of global health affairs, as the highest-ranking government officials. A roundtable with representatives of medical equipment makers was also scheduled.

History of controversy
Osteocentre is no stranger to controversy in Bulgaria. As one of the biggest tissue banks in Bulgaria, it was among the main beneficiaries of the Transplants Act, approved by Parliament in 2002.

The act, controversially, allows harvesting of human tissue from dead people by silent consent. Unless the person explicitly denied permission by filing a form with his or her general practitioner – people who have no medical insurance or general practitioner in Bulgaria can file the form at their municipality – their tissue can be harvested. Immediate family can prevent the harvesting if, in "reasonable time", they do so in writing.

The tissue, usually ligament or bone, is later treated and used as allograft transplants. Osteocentre’s first tissue harvesting contract in Bulgaria was with the Transplants Agency in 2002, then called the National Centre for Transplantation, which, critics said, created a conflict of interest for the agency because it is also the government body overseeing all transplant-related activities.

Osteocentre now has a contract with the Euro Atlantic Transplant Alliance, a Bulgarian non-profit foundation, according to a statement Osteotech filed in April 2008, when the contract was renewed for four years.

Critics claim that the foundation is only a front for Osteocentre, an allegation that Hichev rejected in 2008. The foundation had renowned doctors and hospital heads on its board, Hichev said at the time, as quoted by Dnevnik daily. He did not give names, nor does the foundation have a website.

Nanev’s visit is now being investigated for a possible conflict of interest by the State Agency for National Security (SANS). Nanev, who denies all allegations, said that he would resign if SANS found any wrongdoing by him.

He said that the reason that he had accepted the invitation was that he had been told in advance that there were no legal issues with the trip. He said that the trip would yield benefits. If Bulgarian authorities had paid the bills, he would have been criticised for spending taxpayers’ money, he said.

  • Print
  • Send via email
  • Translate to
  • Share:

Comments

Anonymous Gerald Kelly Sun, Jan 16 2011 08:26 CET

This just goes to show that the Bulgarian people think that everything that is done is corrupt. The fact it Mr. Nanev's visit also included a meeting with his American counterpart in the states about the issue of tissue transplant. This is the reason that Bulgaria will continue to live in the stone ages in the medical field. Tissue transplant is a live saving treatment and to bring this to Bulgaria will go to help many people. It's a shame that the narrow minded people of Bulgaria don't see that, this is why your health care system is in the [...]

Read the full comment 18th century. Good luck with that.

Anonymous*******Mon, Feb 01 2010 19:42 CET

This comment has been removed by the moderator because it contained foul, abusive or discriminating language

Anonymous smiley Sun, Jan 31 2010 11:48 CET

But his salary was still being paid at the time and by the taxpayer!!! So taxpayers money is spent. Wholly disgusting.


To post comments, please, Login or Register.


Please read the The Sofia Echo forum comments policy.

Bulgarian Prime Minister nominates new Health Minister

Professor Anna Maria Borissova set to replace Bozhidar Nanev, who resigned after being charged by prosecutors.

Bitter medicine

In a historic move, prosecutors press charges against a minister in office who resigned hours later

Controversy surrounds Bulgarian health minister’s US trip

Investigators are looking into the November 2009 trip to the United States by Health Minister Bozhidar Nanev and senior officials that was hosted by a US-based company.

Borissov will meet doctors over funding crisis

Boiko Borissov will hold talks with hospitals directors and representatives from emergency medical facilities nationwide.

Health check

Health care reform proposals are hotly debated in Bulgaria, but are the right questions being asked?

Bulgaria declares flu epidemic at an end

Bulgaria’s Health Ministry announced on November 20 2009 that the flu epidemic declared two weeks earlier is at an end as rates of infection decline. The announcement coincides with reports of two deaths from A (H1N1) flu in Bulgaria.

Bulgaria's health sector to receive additional 350M leva in funding

The Bulgarian health sector is poised to receive a much-needed financial boost of 350 million leva, according to a memorandum on November 17, signed by the ruling GERB party, the Blue Coalition, Finance Minister Simeon Dyankov and Health Minister Bozhidar Nanev

More in this category

Average monthly salary in Bulgaria rose in Q4 2011, statistics institute says

In the fourth quarter of 2011, the average monthly salary increased to 727 leva, 4.9 per cent higher than in Q3, the National Statistics Institute says.

Global food prices rebound, FAO says

For the first time in six months, global food prices rose overall in January 2012, the UN Food and Agricultural Organisation said.

Bulgaria mulls tighter regulation of bank fees - updated

The package will be discussed with the Association of Bulgarian Banks before the amendments are submitted to Parliament.

Bulgarian ICT Watch event in March

Debate at the half-day event will cover what has been achieved so far and what further can be done by the Bulgarian Government to support development of the market.

Movers and shakers

Selectivity, not popularity, is the driving force behind Sofia's most exclusive members' only club.

Appointments

British Council

British Council

Lyubov Kostova was appointed country manager of British Council Bulgaria effective January 1, replacing Tony Buckby, who left in October 2011 to take a similar position at British Council Greece. Kostova has been with British Council Bulgaria for 11 years, as public communications manager and, since 2008, as the head of project and partnerships department. Prior to joining the British Council, Kostova was head of international activities at the National Academy for Theatre and Cinema Arts (NATFIZ). She has a degree in Indian studies from Kliment Ohridski Sofia University.

CEZ

CEZ

Stefan Apostolov is the new chief executive of CEZ Razpredelenie Bulgaria, the power transmission subsidiary of Czech energy company CEZ in the country. He replaces interim chief executive Ales Damm, who remains the chairperson of the CEZ Razpredelenie management board. Apostolov has 30 years of experience in the energy sector, joining CEZ in 2007 as director of customer service and was later appointed as head of business development. Apostolov has a master's degree in electric systems from the Belorussian National Technical University in Minsc, management diplomas from Open University London and New Bulgarian University, as well as a master's degree in business administration from Plovdiv University.

BASF Bulgaria

BASF Bulgaria

Valentina Dikanska is the new general manager of chemical industry giant BASF subsidiary in Bulgaria, taking over from Herbert Fisch, BASF vice president for Southeastern Europe. Dikanska, who started her career as an expert in the Finance Ministry, joined BASF Bulgaria as director of finance and administration in 2002. She becomes the first Bulgarian to hold the top management position in the company in its 40-year history on the Bulgarian market. Dikanska holds a master's degree in economics from the University for National and World Economy in Sofia.

Rompetrol Bulgaria

Rompetrol Bulgaria

Alexander Albin has been appointed chief executive of fuel distributor Rompetrol Bulgaria, replacing Nichita Sorin, who left to become chief executive of Rompetrol Gaz in Romania. Albin was previously chief executive of Rompetrol Georgia. He has more than 15 years of experience in the oil and gas industry; prior to joining Romania's oil group Rompetrol in 2008 as an adviser, he oversaw operations at Atyrau refinery in Kazakhstan, owned by Rompetrol's parent company KazMunaiGaz. He previously held top management positions at two other leading Kazakh oil and gas companies.