Tue, Feb 09 2010

Gabriel Hershman

The English Angle: Doomed

Fri, Nov 27 2009 09:58 CET 1396 Views 4 Comments
It was a vast monolithic body, an enforced union of diverse countries with an undemocratic central decision-making structure led by immovable apparatchiks. Its subjects felt removed from its machinations and powerless before its bureaucracy.  Eventually it collapsed through its own inherent contradictions. States seceded and then declared independence.

I refer - of course! -  to the European Union, probably circa 2015 to 2020. I simply don’t believe this federation is feasible. When nobody has heard of recent appointees (Herman van Rompuy and Catherine Ashton) you know the game’s up.

A lot of nonsense has been talked about the EU. What started out as a loose conglomeration of states in Western Europe (and nothing wrong with that) now resembles an elephant with arteriosclerosis.

The United States of Europe will never wash with the voters. Neither will absurd statements trotted out to defend its purpose. "The EU has already made wars between its members unthinkable". This is one of many favourite idiotic pronouncements. The federal nature of this giant and unwieldy structure is likely to foment nationalism, not submerge it.

The absence of war between its principal members to date has nothing to do with the EU - do we believe the UK and Germany would have been fighting without the EU apparatus to "restrain" them? - and wrangling over the Iraq war has poured cold water over talk of a joint foreign policy, let alone an army.

EU funds - and they always talk of "funds" as if it sprang magically from an EU tree in Brussels - is simply a socialistic transfer of money from wealthier taxpayers in a privileged corner of Europe to a poorer one. In boom times, taxpayers in richer countries may not rebel but in a crisis they will grow more recalcitrant. Above all, the EU’s worst feature is its lack of accountability. Did ordinary people elect Durao Barroso? And Van Rompuy? How do we get rid of them?

Europe is too diverse a beast ever to sing the same tune. What does Turkey have in common with Europe? How will Europeans react to an unprecedented wave of immigrants? There’s already enough dissatisfaction with immigration as it is. When  will the expansion end? Will North African countries join?

Small is beautiful. People want to govern their own affairs and they want to see a transparent process linked to their will. The EU is the polar opposite. Like the Soviet Union, I suspect it’s doomed to collapse. Watch this space.

Comments

Anonymous opel astra Sun, Jan 31 2010 22:40 CET
Inappropriate comment?

The EU parliament has become a puffer fish it will eventually burst,
thy are wasting to much money on wages and expenses, and what is the point of having two Parliament building one is enough.

Anonymous EU Hope Sat, Dec 12 2009 04:48 CET
Inappropriate comment?

The article is written by an Englishman all right, amazing he didn't use the term wog.

Anonymous Opportunity Knocks Fri, Nov 27 2009 23:54 CET
Inappropriate comment?

As an past immigrant yourself are you a drain or a benefit on the host country in UK/Portugal/France?
You say 'unprecedented wave of immigrants? There’s already enough dissatisfaction with immigration as it is'- well not really it's a smaller more interconnected world and all the better for it if you can adapt.

Anonymous*******Fri, Nov 27 2009 15:49 CET

This comment has been removed by the moderator because it contained foul, abusive or discriminating language

Write comment

Name:Comment:

Generate new code
Send your comment

By posting a comment, you are deemed to have read and agreed to our
Acceptable Use Policy.

The English Angle: Orange squeezer

It’s that clink-clink time again.

More in this category

Living Bulgaria: Confusion reigns

With global warming being high on everyone’s agenda these days, Bulgaria, the rest of Europe, and even the British Isles have been through the coldest winter for several decades.

Macro: Losing the plot

Even casual filmgoers know that in the horror genre, the "monster" never really goes away, no matter how soundly defeated by the protagonist(s).

Offline: Chinese finger trap

China and Google are far away, but recent attacks on Google’s servers that were said to have originated in China do – or at least should – have a bearing on local politics in Bulgaria.

Living Bulgaria : Health and safety

A few weeks away from Bulgaria over the festive season gave me time to reflect on the balance between living dangerously and taking control of our health and safety.

Macro: Wasted energy

For Bulgaria, the only need that Russian energy projects would satisfy is that felt by some politicians to "turn Bulgaria into the energy centre of the Balkans".