Fri, Feb 10 2012

Euro story

Fri, Oct 16 2009 10:01 CET 6974 Views 2 Comments
Euro story

HORSE BEFORE CART: Bulgaria may not know when it will be allowed into the eurozone, but is already certain what should be on its future coin – the Madara horseman, an early medieval large rock relief carved on the Madara plateau near Shoumen in north-eastern Bulgaria.

Photo: Klearchos Kapoutsis

Divided as Bulgaria’s political landscape is, very few topics receive unanimous support from politicians and voters alike, but the need to maintain the currency board is likely the issue that comes closest.

After the banking crisis of 1995/96 decimated Bulgaria’s banking system and erased the life savings of hundreds of thousands, the currency board helped restore some degree of confidence in banks, as well as helping Bulgaria’s economy recover.

But some degree of mistrust remains and any talk concerning abolishing the currency board and the current value of the lev pegged to the euro is viewed with suspicion as an attempt by a few in the know to benefit at the expense of the many.

The lower interest rates on loans in euro during the credit boom in recent years have led thousands to take loans in euro. The share of euro-denominated loans and advances was 57.5 per cent at the end of August 2009, according to central bank data. For corporate loans and advances, the ratio was 70.2 per cent.

Maintaining the current value of the peg ensures that a large number of those companies and individuals would not be driven to bankruptcy because of currency rate fluctuations. The only real guarantee of that, however, would be Bulgaria adopting the euro at the current peg.

Early days
Since the currency board agreement was put in place in 1997, periodic speculation in the media about whether Bulgaria should continue using the existing arrangement has caused mild unrest.

In May 2000, just two months after the European Commission started full membership talks with Sofia, the governor of the Bulgarian National Bank (BNB) at the time, Svetoslav Gavriiski, was forced to speak out to shoot down speculation that the issue of floating the lev was being discussed by the central bank.

"The currency board has proven its advantages in preventing our country in the past three years from external and domestic crises that have occurred before its introduction," he said on May 11 2000. "I do not see reasons to cancel the system. This has not been discussed in the central bank nor in the government." Already then, the issue of a candidate or member state unilaterally adopting the euro, without the blessing of the European Central Bank (ECB), was causing considerable dismay in Western Europe. After Estonia floated the issue, only to have it forcefully rejected, Gavriiski felt compelled to expressly rule out such a scenario.

"Unilateral adoption of the euro prior to formal EU membership would not produce any advantages, especially after the ECB has made it clear that it would not support similar moves elsewhere," he said.

Ambitious target
The centre-right government that elected Gavriiski to head the BNB and which began European Union membership negotiations was voted out of office in June 2001. The new government headed by former monarch Simeon Saxe-Coburg continued, which picked up where its predecessor left off as far as EU accession talks were concerned, proved to be more bullish on euro adoption.

Consistently posting Budget surpluses, free of currency variations because of the currency board and with government debt low, the new cabinet and the BNB governor it appointed, Ivan Iskrov, were confident that Bulgaria could join the exchange rate mechanism (ERM-2) as soon as the country became a member of the EU on January 1 2007. Under the Maastricht criteria for adopting the euro, a member state must keep its currency trading in a 15 per cent band against the euro in ERM-2 for two years before joining the European monetary union.

Just days after 10 countries joined the EU in the bloc’s largest expansion, Iskrov said that Bulgaria’s currency board, like those in the Baltic states, meant that the country could join the ERM-2 right on accession.

"Our estimate is that if we join the European Union on January 1 2007, and there are no negative signs that make this appear unlikely, we hope to be ready to enter the euro zone immediately," he said on May 4 2004.

Several months later, Iskrov and then-finance minister Milen Velchev made the target official. "We declare that Bulgaria will aim to enter the eurozone in 2009," Velchev said on November 25 2004.

On the same occasion, as if seeking to assuage lingering doubts, Iskrov said: "In practice, we are announcing from today that Bulgaria will keep its currency board regime, not only until joining the European Union, but until joining the euro zone, and at the current peg."
  • Print
  • Send via email
  • Translate to
  • Share:

Comments

Anonymous expat Mon, Oct 19 2009 19:00 CET

no one finds this interesting for commenting....?

Anonymous Expat Fri, Oct 16 2009 11:06 CET

It is very interesting to observe the discussion about currency board and joining EUR in BG since some time.

Either continuing currency board or devaluation, I think both ways are practicable for BG.
Having in mind that EUR is dominated by German FX policy, which was always a policy of hard currency and conservatism (as DEM was previously). in the 70ies and 80ie other countries (e.g. AT ) had a currency board to DEM. The hard currency block had always very difficult times, because all companies and employees had to give their best effort [...]

Read the full comment to be more competitive and productive than other countries like IT which evaluated their currency and made their services (Tourism) or products cheaper compared to hard currency countries (DE and AT), which focused on productivity and quality (made in Germany).
Having this in mind and projecting to BG will mean that BG has to make a enormous huge effort to make its companies and employees much, much, much more productive and improve quality in light year dimension in order be be successful compared to other countries in the region which just devaluated to be attractive.

Having said this I am conviced that it will be a very burdensome and hard way to recovery for BG (having the currency board in place). The recovery will be very slow and takes some time. But if the country, comprised by the mutual effort of each and every citizen, succeeds in constant improvement BG will arise out of the crisis much stronger than comparing neighborhood contries - but it will be a very long and hard road to walk for everyone !!


To post comments, please, Login or Register.


Please read the The Sofia Echo forum comments policy.

Bulgaria’s current account deficit shrinks threefold amid downturn

Overall, the balance of payments remained negative for 2009, with a 649 million euro deficit compared with a surplus of 674.2 million euro for 2008.

PM: Bulgaria to launch euro zone bid in January 2010

The debt crisis erupting across the currency bloc could harm Bulgaria's application, Prime Minister Boiko Borissov says in an interview with The Wall Street Journal.

Bulgaria’s banks will end 2009 with 700 million leva profit – Iskrov

Loans that are non-performing and in arrears have increased this year, but the banking system is sufficiently well-capitalised and has solid ‘shock absorbers’ to cope, central Bulgarian National Bank Governor Ivan Iskrov says.

What to do with the euro?

Accepting Bulgaria into the eurozone is the best alternative for the EU

Bulgaria to seek eurozone entry within GERB’s term – Finance Minister

Bulgaria joining the euro zone is a top priority for Prime Minister Boiko Borissov's GERB Government, and the plan is to achieve this during this term of office, Deputy Prime Minister and Finance Minister Simeon Dyankov said on September 16 2009 in an interview with news agency Reuters.

Euro path

What will the future bring? Possible exchange rate and currency board scenarios in view of Bulgaria joining the euro area.

The great euro debate

Already at odds with the European Commission, Bulgaria now risks angering the European Central Bank with talk of unilaterally adopting the euro

Credit crunch: Debate on Bulgaria eloping with the euro continues

As realisation began to sink in that the global financial crisis could have a significant negative impact on Bulgaria, in recent weeks some voices in the country's political and private sectors began to argue for unilateral adoption of the euro. An attempt by Brussels to throw cold water on the debate has not succeeded.

More in this category

Average monthly salary in Bulgaria rose in Q4 2011, statistics institute says

In the fourth quarter of 2011, the average monthly salary increased to 727 leva, 4.9 per cent higher than in Q3, the National Statistics Institute says.

Global food prices rebound, FAO says

For the first time in six months, global food prices rose overall in January 2012, the UN Food and Agricultural Organisation said.

Bulgaria mulls tighter regulation of bank fees - updated

The package will be discussed with the Association of Bulgarian Banks before the amendments are submitted to Parliament.

Bulgarian ICT Watch event in March

Debate at the half-day event will cover what has been achieved so far and what further can be done by the Bulgarian Government to support development of the market.

Movers and shakers

Selectivity, not popularity, is the driving force behind Sofia's most exclusive members' only club.

Appointments

British Council

British Council

Lyubov Kostova was appointed country manager of British Council Bulgaria effective January 1, replacing Tony Buckby, who left in October 2011 to take a similar position at British Council Greece. Kostova has been with British Council Bulgaria for 11 years, as public communications manager and, since 2008, as the head of project and partnerships department. Prior to joining the British Council, Kostova was head of international activities at the National Academy for Theatre and Cinema Arts (NATFIZ). She has a degree in Indian studies from Kliment Ohridski Sofia University.

CEZ

CEZ

Stefan Apostolov is the new chief executive of CEZ Razpredelenie Bulgaria, the power transmission subsidiary of Czech energy company CEZ in the country. He replaces interim chief executive Ales Damm, who remains the chairperson of the CEZ Razpredelenie management board. Apostolov has 30 years of experience in the energy sector, joining CEZ in 2007 as director of customer service and was later appointed as head of business development. Apostolov has a master's degree in electric systems from the Belorussian National Technical University in Minsc, management diplomas from Open University London and New Bulgarian University, as well as a master's degree in business administration from Plovdiv University.

BASF Bulgaria

BASF Bulgaria

Valentina Dikanska is the new general manager of chemical industry giant BASF subsidiary in Bulgaria, taking over from Herbert Fisch, BASF vice president for Southeastern Europe. Dikanska, who started her career as an expert in the Finance Ministry, joined BASF Bulgaria as director of finance and administration in 2002. She becomes the first Bulgarian to hold the top management position in the company in its 40-year history on the Bulgarian market. Dikanska holds a master's degree in economics from the University for National and World Economy in Sofia.

Rompetrol Bulgaria

Rompetrol Bulgaria

Alexander Albin has been appointed chief executive of fuel distributor Rompetrol Bulgaria, replacing Nichita Sorin, who left to become chief executive of Rompetrol Gaz in Romania. Albin was previously chief executive of Rompetrol Georgia. He has more than 15 years of experience in the oil and gas industry; prior to joining Romania's oil group Rompetrol in 2008 as an adviser, he oversaw operations at Atyrau refinery in Kazakhstan, owned by Rompetrol's parent company KazMunaiGaz. He previously held top management positions at two other leading Kazakh oil and gas companies.