Sat, Nov 21 2009

Gabriel Hershman

The English Angle: Look back in anger

Fri, Jul 03 2009 10:00 CET 1345 Views 2 Comments
If you have a son never send him to an all boys’ school. These institutions, which, needless to say, scar the landscape of that strange island called the United Kingdom, can screw you up big time. My all boys’ school was like a microcosm of Nazi Germany. All male classes, unsoftened by female influences, became a survival of the fittest jungle. By this I mean that a ‘fuehrer’ naturally emerges, not by virtue of his finer morality or upstanding character, but by dint of physical prowess or his ability to impose his will on the collective. That ‘leader’ then acquires a circle of sycophantic supplicants. The group becomes a reflection of that person’s power. Those who dissent or fail to win the leader’s favour are ostracised.

Little boys are also natural anti-Semites because, by the same token, they tend to single out anyone who does not conform to the ‘brute is best’ role model. Unless Jewish boys are exceptionally sporty or incredibly charismatic, they are liable to be stigmatised. Jewish schoolchildren TEND to be more intellectual and studious than the rest. There is a good reason for this. It is called persecution. This means that parents often inculcate in their children a will to succeed - a thirst for higher knowledge. But this can make Jewish schoolchildren too conspicuous. At my school, anti-Semitism was not exclusive to the boys either. Even staff were known to make anti-Semitic utterances. This, I hasten to add, was 25 years ago. Hopefully, the situation is a little better now.

Defendants of segregated schools say that study is best conducted away from the distractions of sex. Crass nonsense. Sex is an ever present part of adolescence; its suppression simply does not work. Survivors of single sex schools can be emotionally damaged and lacking in inter-personal skills.

Boys’ schools also encourage grotesque sadism. We were forced to take part in cross-country runs, come rain, shine or minus nine. No exceptions. Disabilities were frowned upon. As a stammering student of English, French, Spanish, and German, every lesson of mine involved oral work and reading aloud to the class. No exceptions and no dispensations, even though my father went to the school and discussed the matter.

Boys who were not particularly robust so hated the prospect of compulsory rugby sessions that they would do anything to get out of it. Elaborate notes - some actually concocted by the boys themselves but purporting to be from their parents - were drafted to exempt themselves. If I have an abiding image of my schooldays it’s of a boy who looked like a fragile twig freezing to death on the sidelines of a snowy pitch before being thrown into the rugger scrum.

Some would say all this was character building. I’m not so sure. I actually came away loathing some of the people there with a passion. So here is a warning - don’t let your child put his hand in the fire and get burnt. Avoid these barbaric places. Life’s too short.

Comments

Anonymous Tony Warner Fri, Jul 03 2009 21:26 CET
Inappropriate comment?

Unfortunately girls do better academically in single sex schools so there is a huge oush in that direction. My experience is that boys from single sex schools, especially those who do not have sisters, make extremely bad boyfriends and husbands and girls from single sex schools tend to be socially less adept as well.

Anonymous Aristotle Fri, Jul 03 2009 21:07 CET
Inappropriate comment?

Entirely agreed ! (In my experience the only way to dodge rugby was to learn to play a musical instrument - the music lessons took place on "games afternoons", and the school very fortunately gave equal weight to musicianship and sporting prowess.

Write comment

Name:Comment:

Generate new code
Send your comment
The English Angle: An unsuitable match

Residing in a small community gave me the chance to observe, say, four couples close-up.

The English Angle: ‘I’ll fump yer...’

The latest survey reveals British holidaymakers are the most loathed of any nationality throughout the world. Well, by the time you read this I’ll be on the beach in Albufeira in the Algarve, which has been effectively colonised by British holidaymakers.

More in this category

Legal Alien: The Pizza Connection

Finance Minister Simeon Dyankov’s use of pizza to illustrate the 2010 Budget – thin crust, scant topping – inspired two Sofia restaurants to turn into reality the Dyankov Pizza; but Bulgaria’s political pantry offers many more possibilities.

My Bulgaria: Tricked

Knowing Borissov’s sensitivity to criticism, impeachment talks hit a bull’s-eye and Borissov fell into the trap.

Macro: Fiscal reservations

Every Bulgarian, it is sometimes said, is an expert in matters of finance and knows how to fix the economy.

Offline: IT failure

A November report by the Bulgarian National Audit Office on Government spending on IT hardware and training in education showed chaos that bordered on the incomprehensible.

The English Angle: Happiness...

Happiness can hit when you don’t search for it. Back in the UK, I once lived in a posh block in central London.