Thu, Nov 05 2009

Non-partisan candidates

Fri, Jun 26 2009 10:01 CET 998 Views
Non-partisan candidates

Angel Hristov, second from the left, and Plamen Galev, second right, on their way out of Sofia central prison escorted by their lawyers
Photo: Anelia Nikolova

A new term has entered the lexicon of Bulgaria’s political debate after Gergana Passi, European Affairs Minister, said on June 18 that the "Galevisation of Bulgaria’s image would find its way into the upcoming European Commission interim report".

The report, which will examine the state of Bulgaria’s judiciary and law enforcement, is expected to come out after the July 5 elections in Bulgaria. Yet Passi’s words were the first serious indicator of how the outside world sees the new feature in Bulgarian politics, that of majority candidates.

Following the introduction of the new rule that 31 out of 240 Parliamentary seats can be elected by a majority vote, controversial businessman Plamen Galev and his partner, Angel Hristov, decided to run for Parliament. This afforded them immunity from prosecution during the election campaign. The court was forced to release them from Sofia central prison, where they had been since December 2008, accused of spearheading a criminal group in their home town of Doupnitsa.

Legally, there was nothing wrong with the court’s ruling because both individuals met all the conditions to run for Parliament. They had no previous convictions and all their registration papers were in order.

From a moral point of view, however, Bulgarian and foreign media raised concerns that two individuals, whose public image is far from unblemished, had exploited a loophole that gives even criminal defendants - on the basis that they are innocent until proven guilty - the right to run for public office.

The rule about granting prospective MPs immunity from prosecution was introduced exactly with the intention of protecting them from an abuse of power. If such a rule were not in place then any parliamentary candidate could be accused of any offence in order to bar them from an election. By the time charges were dropped, the election campaign could have run its course.

When working on this rule, however, legislators failed to foresee the "Galevi scenario" whereby a loyal crowd of supporters in their home town, combined with a low turnout, could send them to Parliament. At first dismissed lightly, the Galevi ‘threat’ has now been taken seriously by Passi and then by President Georgi Purvanov, the main advocate of Bulgaria having MPs elected by a majority vote.

On June 22, Purvanov criticised parties for minsinterpreting his idea about majority candidates and even distanced himself from the measure by saying that he was not the first person to propose it. Purvanov said that those facing criminal charges choosing to run for Parliament were "a provocation to the democratic principles of the state and society".

Without specifically mentioning Galev and Hristov, Purvanov said that there had to be some way to prevent such individuals from running for Parliament. Unfortunately, he did not say how this could happen and if such a (new) rule would somehow contravene the "innocent until proven guilty" key judicial cornerstone. He said that if such people made it to Parliament, they would "harm the image of Bulgaria and our perception of democracy".      

The Galev scenario is not totally without precedent, however. In 2005, Vladimir Kouzov was elected as  MP for ultra-nationalist Ataka party despite being investigated for paedophilia. When he was elected to Parliament the investigation was put on hold, as is now the case with Galev. It was only restarted after Parliament stripped Kouzov of his immunity.

In 2009, he got a three-year suspended sentence and was expelled from Parliament, so proving that legal mechanisms do exist to convict a person even if he has immunity provided prosecutors have evidence to prove a crime.

Purvanov raised further concerns that not that many majority candidates were supported by initiative committees (requiring a minimum seven supporters) as is the case with Plamen Galev.

A total of 4652 candidates have registered for the elections. Of this number, 357 are running as majority candidates. Significantly, a great number of these candidates are standing as both proportional and majority candidates.

All the party leaders, for example, are running as both majority and proportional candidates so that they can - firstly - guarantee their seat in Parliament and - secondly - pull one more person from the election ticket in. Purvanov fears that parties have started solving their internal problems by sending one candidate to stand as a majority one and another as a proportional one, so undermining the idea of having more non-partisan candidates.

Ironically, one of the few non-partisan candidates happens to be Plamen Galev.

Write comment

Name:Comment:

Generate new code
Send your comment
EC interim report on Bulgaria judiciary would not recommend safeguard clause - radio

The report will be published on July 22 2009 when Bulgaria's new cabinet is expected to be appointed

Galevi brothers remain free on bail despite failing to win seats in Parliament

The only way they could be returned to prison is if they break bail terms, which is very unlikely, prosecutor says, while asking the court to restart their trial.

6.8 million Bulgarians eligible to vote

Election authorities register 21 observers from the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe

Defendants should be barred from standing for Parliament, opposition party demands

After the example of the "Galevi brothers" who were set free on bail to stand for Parliament, the Order, Lawfulness, Justice party is seeking a change in the law

Galevi brothers' exit from prison – photo gallery

Plamen Galev and Angel Hristov, commonly referred as the "Galevi brothers", were set free from Sofia central prison on 50 000 leva bail each on June 16. They were released after both were registered as candidates for Parliament ahead of the July 5 elections.

Galevi brothers set free to stand for Parliament

After six months under arrest, the two controversial businessmen were freed to campaign.

More in this category

Influenza update: more regions fall to the strain as one area recovers

Health Minister: laboratories have concluded that the influenza pandemic is not seasonal, but indeed, caused by the H1N1 strain, swine flu

German embassy in Sofia to open its doors on November 7 in symbolic gesture

Decision comes to commemorate the 20th anniversary of the toppling of the Berlin Wall

PM: SANS lost trust and confidence at home, abroad

German publication Spiegel has obtained a ‘secret’ report from the Bulgarian State Agency for National Security (SANS)pertaining to internal affairs for the first six months of 2009

Mountain Rescue Patrol search for disappeared hiker in central Stara Planina

Fluctuating weather conditions can make conditions in the mountains more precarious than usual

President Vujanovic of Montenegro on official visit to Bulgaria

Bulgarian and Montenegrin presidents set to sign bilateral agreements for enhanced economic cooperation in the energy sector