Sun, Nov 08 2009

Gabriel Hershman

Blog: Alan Johnson for PM? Silly season arrives early...

Mon, May 25 2009 15:15 CET 2484 Views 8 Comments
Blog: Alan Johnson for PM? Silly season arrives early...

Future PM? Health secretary Alan Johnson


Photo: Wikipedia

I sometimes wonder who writes leader columns for quality newspapers in the UK these days. Probably kids of 25. The Times, once considered the most prestigious daily in the country but which now employs stand-up comic Frank Skinner as one of its star columnists, is now urging Alan Johnson to "seize the mantle" and be ready to assume the Labour leadership and, er, coincidentally, become prime minister. (http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/politics/article6355300.ece) Ha ha...nice one...

Sometimes one wonders if the people who write this stuff have nothing better to do. Given the state of Britain – economic crisis, declining morality, a plague of drunkenness, escalating street crime and general hooliganism, appalling displays of corruption and greed on the part of MP's – you would have thought this would be enough to keep leader writers busy. But, if in doubt, as they say, focus on the personalities instead.

Back in the old days to be prime minister required a certain statesmanlike quality – that indefinable 'gravitas' so often alluded to in the circles of Westminster. But also  – and I know this may sound incredibly old- fashioned – you had to have experience of high office, notably experience either as foreign secretary or chancellor OR at least a long portfolio of shadowing these great offices OR a healthy stint as leader of the opposition. James Callaghan held all four 'great' offices of state. Margaret Thatcher was education secretary but then spent four years as opposition leader, so had plenty of time to shadow both Harold Wilson and Callaghan. Besides, nobody doubted she was exceptionally skilled whatever view one took of her politics.

The rot set in with John Major –  the belief that a jumped up Johnny can somehow be parachuted into Number 10 and dramaticaly reinvigorate not only his party's fortunes but also fill the boots of his predecessor. Major was, of course, dramatically over-promoted. The Conservatives should have lost the April 1992 election and it was only the public's lack of faith in his rival Neil Kinnock that granted Major a stay of execution.

I have met Alan Johnson once –  the current health secretary stood smoking a succession of cigarettes outside a tourism conference in Faro, Portugal in 2002. I have nothing against him but somehow I doubt that he is really suited to holding the highest office in the land. To his credit I suspect he knows that too. So let's wait until August before we start indulging in silly season.

Of course, Brown must go, but it should now be up to the people to decide. We can't just jettison a prime minister a few months before an election and insert Johnson. That would make Britain even more of a laughing stock throughout the world than it already is. Let the voters decide. Robbing them of their right to deliver their judgement on Brown's period in office (remember that he too was unelected) just wouldn't be cricket...

Comments

Anonymous Matt-Serfaklar Wed, Aug 19 2009 17:01 CET
Inappropriate comment?

Sometimes it's really that simple, isn't it? I feel a little stupid for not thinking of this myself/earlier, though.

Anonymous Roulett Technique Mon, Aug 17 2009 20:40 CET
Inappropriate comment?

Sometimes it's really that simple, isn't it? I feel a little stupid for not thinking of this myself/earlier, though.

Anonymous Money Fast Tue, Aug 04 2009 02:16 CET
Inappropriate comment?

Hey, ok, I get it, I guess - but does this really work?

Anonymous MichaellaS Tue, Jul 21 2009 15:27 CET
Inappropriate comment?

tks for the effort you put in here I appreciate it!

Anonymous Gratis Film Downloaden Sat, Jul 18 2009 20:48 CET
Inappropriate comment?

Hey, ok, I get it, I guess - but does this really work?

Anonymous Money Chris Sat, Jul 18 2009 02:27 CET
Inappropriate comment?

Hey, ok, I get it, I guess - but does this really work?

Anonymous Chris Mon, May 25 2009 23:10 CET
Inappropriate comment?

A bit harsh with the 'plague of drunkenness' and 'general hooliganism' comments - I can't say it paints a fair picture of Britain as I see it. Absolutely no problem with the comments about 'appalling displays of corruption and greed on the part of MP's' - I'm definitely with you on that one (along with everyone else in the UK I'd wager).

There will always be speculation about the Labour leadership though, even from the Times - they need to sell papers after all. They're certainly not the only 'quality paper' to raise the question of Labour party leader candidacy (although many would still refute that the Times is as prestigious a newspaper since it was taken over by the Murdoch empire).

I don't think many British people would view a new Prime Minister who wasn't voted in through a General Election as a legitimate leader. The only thing Gordon Brown can hope for is a consensus within the Labour party that replacing the leader would be more damaging for the party's chances of holding onto their seats in the next election.

Regardless, it's a slow news day in Britain. A national holiday and good weather (for a change). You'd almost forgive the Times running the regular gossip story of 'who will oust Gordon Brown now' - it's become as predictable as the 'when will Ronaldo go to Real Madrid' story. At best, Johnson is probably positioning himself for taking over as an opposition leader. If he does, he may well end up being a fall guy like Michael Howard or Iain Duncan Smith who has to make way for a truly electable Labour government in the future. Though if the Conservatives are elected in and are afforded a stay in government as long as Tony Blair was, then that could be anything over 10 years away - and that is a long time in anyone's book. Time enough for David Milliband to mature into the post of shadow leader and potential PM? Oh, wait I'm speculating now.

Anonymous cherieB Mon, May 25 2009 22:25 CET
Inappropriate comment?

Still do not get it Gabriel or do you??

New Labours Job is done...wealth extraction complete, now we must pay !

Write comment

Name:Comment:

Generate new code
Send your comment

More in this category

Late delivery: The Sofia Echo email bulletin

A technical glitch caused the October 27 issue of The Sofia Echo email bulletin to go out to subscribers later than scheduled.

Blewett revisited

Blewett's latest production on the lives of former Mogilino inmates, shows that it is not just the children that have undergone impressive transformations.

Is Obama's Nobel a shade premature?

The last American president to win such an accolade was Jimmy Carter in 2002, having helped broker the Egypt-Israel peace deal in 1978 while he was president.

Weekend blog: Roman Polanski, the cinema's genius and enfant terrible

Roman Polanski's actions back in 1977 may have been inexcusable but that won't stop his fans revisiting his movie masterpieces

Blog: Michael Shields and the media

The British tabloid campaign to get Michael Shields freed from jail could be a case study for spin doctors and activists.