Sat, Feb 11 2012

Fortress Switzerland or open doors?

Sun, Feb 08 2009 14:27 CET 1438 Views
Fortress Switzerland or open doors?

CROW BAR: Campaign posters in Switzerland against extending the labour market deal with the EU and extending it to Bulgaria and Romania depicted three black crows devouring the Alpine state.

Photo: Agence France Presse

Swiss voters went to the polls on February 8 2009 in a key referendum  to decide whether Switzerland continues to allow unrestricted immigration from within the European Union, with media reports indicating that exit polls showed that the "yes" vote would prevail.

Although Switzerland is not a member of the EU, it has traditionally backed the principle of the free influx of labour of workers from the EU.  In a reciprocal arrangement, about 400 000 Swiss migrants are allowed free access to the EU's labour market.  

Swiss president Hans Rudolf Merz has warned his countrymen that a "no" vote could jeopardise bilaterial ties with the EU. "Our country is opposed to (EU) membership but we recognise that we wouldn't be able to go it alone without ending up in complete isolation and we can't afford that," he said.

The plan to extend free movement of labour has been backed by the bulk of Switzerland's political, economic and business establishment, but polls show that ordinary Swiss voters are split down the middle on the issue. In a survey at the end of January, just 50 per cent supported the motion as opposed to 43 per cent who rejected it and seven per cent who were undecided. This represents a sharp decline from the 67 per cent who supported free movement in a similar referendum nine years ago.

The main opponent of free movement of labour is the right-wing Swiss People's Party. The party's campaign poster depicts ravenous crows pecking away at the Swiss flag. The party also refers to Bulgaria and Romania as "Europe's third world". Hans Fehr, an MP for the Swiss People's Party, said that the atmosphere had changed considerably since the last vote on the issue and that the influx of large numbers of workers from Romania and Bulgaria could undercut home grown salaries . "Now we are in a recession that could be very hard for Swiss business people. It is important for them to have cheap workers and Swiss workers could lose their jobs as a result."

However, Bulgaria's former ambassador to Brussels and Bern, Lea Cohen, said that a "no" vote would be "Switzerland's loss" and said that Bulgaria was not an EU country with a particularly high crime rate. She also cited the number of Bulgarian workers in Switzerland (thought to be about 1000) as proof that Switzerland was not a favoured country for Bulgarian immigrants. Cohen said that Spain and the UK are more popular destinations. She  expressed dismay at the populist nature of the campaign conducted by the the Swiss People's Party and described their poster as in poor taste.

  • Print
  • Send via email
  • Translate to
  • Share:

To post comments, please, Login or Register.


Please read the The Sofia Echo forum comments policy.

Switzerland extends free movement for Bulgaria and Romania

Bulgarians and Romanians will no longer need visas but Switzerland will keep a tighter rein on labour restrictions

Europe must deliver a common immigration policy, MEPs say

Report adopted on April 22 calls for new Europe-wide Schengen visa system, new border policing system, full mobility for immigrants in EU after five years and right to vote in municipal elections.

More in this category

Bulgaria, Romania lambast Dutch anti-immigration website

Foreign ministries criticise website that calls on visitors to lodge complaints against immigrants from Central and Eastern Europe.

European Commission meets target for recruiting Bulgarians, Romanians

‘I am delighted we managed to identify and attract some of the brightest and best people from Bulgaria and Romania to come and work at the European Commission,’ EC Vice-President Maroš Šefčovič said.

Cold spell should ease its grip on Europe next week, World Meteorological Organisation says

The current ‘negative Arctic Oscillation’ – a weather phenomenon which leads to cold conditions in Europe and relatively warmer conditions in the Arctic – should shift into a more neutral pattern within the next two to three weeks.

Cold snap hits Europe; thaw a threat

The extreme cold has been blamed for almost 400 deaths across Europe. In Ukraine, where temperatures have fallen below minus 30 degrees Celsius, the cold is blamed for at least 122 deaths. Many of the victims were homeless.

Bulgaria among EU’s lowest government debt-to-GDP ratios – Eurostat

At the end of Q3 2011, the highest government debt to GDP ratio was in Greece, at 159.1 per cent.